• 1.

    Kumar D, et al.. COVID-19: A global transplant perspective on successfully navigating a pandemic [published online ahead of print March 23, 2020]. Am J Transplant doi: 10.1111/ajt.15876.

    • PubMed
    • Search Google Scholar
    • Export Citation

Kidney Transplants Are Cancelled or Rescheduled during COVID-19 Pandemic

Karen Blum
Search for other papers by Karen Blum in
Current site
Google Scholar
Full access

As the COVID-19 pandemic continues to take hold, kidney transplantation programs across the United States and elsewhere have been canceling or postponing many procedures, moving to telephone or video visits with patients, and emphasizing the importance of handwashing and social distancing in their quest to keep their patients safe.

“There’s a lot of unknowns about how SARS-CoV-2 will intersect with organ transplantation,” said Ajit Limaye, MD, professor of medicine and director of the transplant infectious disease program at the University of Washington in Seattle, during an international COVID-19 Town Hall webinar sponsored by the United Network for Organ Sharing, the American Society of Transplantation, and other groups.

“A reasonable expectation is that organ transplant patients with immunosuppression might be at increased risk for acquiring the virus,” Limaye said. “There are a lot of concerns there may be a higher likelihood of them progressing from infection to more severe disease, perhaps as a result of underlying comorbid conditions as well as the impact of immune suppression.” The published data to date on organ transplantation are very limited, he noted.

Meanwhile, many transplantation programs are reducing their operations except for the sickest patients. They’re delaying living donor kidney transplantation, being more selective about deceased donor kidneys, screening donor kidneys and recipients for COVID-19, and postponing evaluations of new patients, in addition to offering telephone or telemedicine visits for most patient checkups. The American Society of Transplantation has suggested limiting the recovery of organs to local teams within donor hospitals unless there are extenuating reasons for the transplanting team to perform the recovery, in an effort to help limit exposure to COVID-19 resulting from travel.

The heavy use of resources such as intensive care unit beds and ventilators means that scaling back transplantation activity is inevitable, said Atul Humar, MD, MSc, director of the transplant center at the University Health Network in Toronto. He and his colleagues developed a phased approach to transplant volume reductions (1) to conserve resources while minimizing the waitlist impact, demonstrating what centers could do at 75%, 50%, or 25% capacity. As of the webinar, his center was operating at 50% volume, doing transplant operations in urgent cases only. For kidney transplantation, they have halted living donor procedures and are doing transplantations only for patients who are highly sensitized and are unlikely to get another offer soon.

“There’s a wide variety in the way people are approaching COVID-19, because no one really seems to know what the right answer is,” nephrologist Andrew Malone, MB, BCh, an assistant professor of medicine at Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis, told Kidney News. “We’re still doing deceased donor transplants for now, but this is in discussion every day. People are thinking of what’s the next step in pulling back, although there’s an argument that there are a group of patients on the transplant waiting list whose risk–benefit would probably favor going ahead and getting a transplant, especially those who are highly sensitized or who have been waiting a long time.”

The University of Maryland School of Medicine in Baltimore, which follows up with about 4000 kidney patients, also has put most kidney transplants on hold, said Matthew Weir, MD, division head of nephrology. Deceased donor operations are proceeding but only in carefully selected cases with a very high likelihood that the kidney will work right away, he said. “We don’t want to keep people in the hospital too long,” he noted. Donors and recipients are tested for COVID-19 before the operation is performed. If patients still want to see Weir in person, he dons a gown, gloves, and mask for the visit. Other patients are seen by telehealth. One of his dialysis units is now a COVID-positive center.

He did recommend a transplantation for one of his recent patients, a 38-year-old woman who had been on the waiting list for 6 years and had an offer of a 5% Kidney Donor Profile Index kidney.

“She might not get another offer like this for years, let alone any other kidney,” Weir said. “I told her with the current testing capabilities, I’d go for it. These are the kinds of questions that come up. It’s a very realistic concern and an issue we have to think about.”

The University of Alabama at Birmingham has gone to 90-plus percent telemedicine visits for kidney patients, said nephrologist Clifton Kew II, MD, a professor of medicine there. He and his colleagues used to see about 30 patients each morning in clinic—a number that has been slashed to four to six. Transplantations are limited there to deceased donor operations as well, and they’re no longer calling in backup patients in case the first intended recipient can’t be operated on. In addition, they’re trying to reduce hospital lengths of stay after surgery, discharging patients home or to a local hotel sooner.

“We’re now doing OK with people with COVID-19, but that could change in 24 hours,” Kew said, noting that the previous week the hospital had gone from four to 40 COVID-19–positive patients overnight. “We don’t know when a whole flotilla of patients may come in, and we may need that room that transplant patient is in. These are very difficult choices that need to be made, but fortunately for kidneys we do have a luxury, and it’s called dialysis.”

Physicians who see transplant patients in the office should consider masking them as soon as they arrive, even if they’re not sick, and rushing them into a room to avoid having them touch areas that may have been touched by other people, advised Marian Michaels, MD, MPH, a professor of pediatrics and surgery at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine

Some hospitals have seen transplant recipients among their COVID-19 patients. During the webinar, particiapants noted that University of Washington Medicine had five transplant recipients, including one who had received a kidney 20 years prior. The 54-year-old man was an inpatient for 13 days before being discharged home, Limaye said. The ASST Papa Giovanni XXIII hospital in Bergamo, Italy, had six COVID-19 patients who had received heart transplants, said Attilo Iacovoni, MD, FESC, of the heart transplantation unit there. Of those, two were in the hospital, two were being treated on an outpatient basis, and two had died.

“The key message is COVID-19 is very aggressive in immunosuppressed patients, and they could get it easily,” Iacovoni said. “If you have an outbreak in your hospital, think twice before treating those with immunosuppression raging.”

Unsurprisingly, kidney patients have been placing many calls to their physicians and transplantation centers, wondering what to do. Some have concerns about cold or virus symptoms like runny nose or fever, and others have asked to be prescribed antiviral medications, said Kew.

“Basically, the advice we give to patients is very similar to what is out there for the general population: Stay away from other people, especially if they’re sick. Wash your hands. Try to limit contact with others as much as possible,” he said. “That’s about the best we can do for them.”

The American Society of Transplantation has COVID-19 resources on its website, including frequently asked questions for transplantation professionals and for transplant recipients and candidates, and a link to the Town Hall webinar: see https://www.myast.org/covid-19-information. The ASN has compiled additional resources at https://www.asn-online.org/ntds/.



Kumar D, et al.. COVID-19: A global transplant perspective on successfully navigating a pandemic [published online ahead of print March 23, 2020]. Am J Transplant doi: 10.1111/ajt.15876.

  • PubMed
  • Search Google Scholar
  • Export Citation